[00:00:00] You spent thousands of dollars on consultative sales training. Your producers came back, and they were better. They listen now. They ask good questions. They restate [00:00:10] the prospect's needs, and revenue didn't move, and I wanna show you why. And let me be clear up front, [00:00:20] consultative selling isn't wrong. The skills are real, and your producers need them, but they're general.
They're the same skills a kid learns in Psych [00:00:30] 101: active listening, clarifying values, restating needs. They'll all work in almost any sale, and [00:00:40] that's the problem because commercial insurance isn't almost any sale. You and every agent you compete with represent the same carriers, [00:00:50] so you can all go get the same price and the same coverage, and every middle market account you want already has an agent.
Welcome to the [00:01:00] Agency Growth Machine podcast, where it's all about transforming potential into profit. And now your host, Randy [00:01:10] Schwantz.
For you to get hired, that agent has to get fired. Consultative selling has nothing to say about either one. [00:01:20] So let me show you a sales call I wrote about in my book called The Wedge, and it happens every day, all day long in this business.
We'll call the producer [00:01:30] Brandon. Brandon walks in pretty cold. He asks the owner to tell him about the business. Well, we've been in business for seven years and we make widgets. And then [00:01:40] Brandon tells about the agency. In business since 1942, we got great markets, great service. He asks if there's anything wrong with the current program.
No, nothing I [00:01:50] can think of. Happy with the service? Yeah, everything seems fine. So Brandon asks for copies of the policies, and then he asks the question almost every producer [00:02:00] has asked. If I can improve your coverage and save you some money, is there any reason why you wouldn't be willing to make a change?
And the prospect's, "Hey, I'm [00:02:10] open-minded. Let's see what you can do." At next week's sales meeting, Brandon reports on his sales call. He says the prospect had no problems and [00:02:20] just wanted a better price. And everybody in the room agrees that all prospects are price buyers and nobody really cares about [00:02:30] service anymore.
Brandon comes back with a proposal. He found a gap in the coverage, he fixed it, and he got a pretty good price from the underwriter. [00:02:40] So he presents his findings. He lets the prospect know the importance of that coverage problem. He shows his price and then asks the prospect if he's ready to put this in place.[00:02:50]
And the prospect compliments him. "Brandon, you sure know your business. Hey, let me review my other quotes and we'll talk in a few days." Well, when [00:03:00] Brandon gets back to the office, he bumps into his sales manager. "Hey, Brandon, how did your meeting go?" Brandon says, "Yeah, really good. I mean, I've, I built a pretty good relationship.
We [00:03:10] fixed his coverage problem and my price was spot on. I think I have a pretty good chance. I, I'll know on Friday." Well, Friday comes and the [00:03:20] phone never rings. At 3:00 in the afternoon, Brandon calls and the prospect is out. So Brandon has a lousy weekend wondering if he's gonna get the deal or not. [00:03:30] On Monday, the prospect calls him back.
"Hey, Brandon, you did a very good job. I was impressed. But unfortunately, the difference [00:03:40] between your pricing and my current agent's just it wasn't great enough to justify a move. So stay in touch and let's look at it again next year." [00:03:50] Brandon makes a note to call him back in nine months. At the next sales meeting, he says, "Yeah, man, we got beat on price again.
I- we, we, we need [00:04:00] better marketing. We, we need better carriers." Now, here's what a consultative sales trainer would say about that call. "That's exactly why [00:04:10] Brandon needs our training." And they're half right. Brandon's first meeting was a little rough. He pitched his agency a little too much. He didn't [00:04:20] probe deeply enough to uncover dissatisfaction.
So sending Brandon to the training, he'll come back better. He doesn't pitch. He [00:04:30] listens. He restates. He asks smarter questions. He finds a real gap. And on the next opportunity, he'll hear [00:04:40] the same thing. "Hey, Brandon, I'm sorry. The difference just wasn't great enough to justify a move." The [00:04:50] training made the first meeting better, and nothing after it changed.
And look, there's three reasons why. Reason number one, no [00:05:00] differentiation. Ask Brandon what makes his agency better. He'll probably say, "Great reputation, great markets, been around a long time, great service." [00:05:10] If he's with a large regional broker, he'll say, "We have in-house loss control and claims management, and we're specialists."
The prospect's eyes roll back in his head [00:05:20] because he's heard it from everyone who walks through the door. This isn't what makes you better. It's more or less the minimum to be in the [00:05:30] game. So after the consultative sales training, Brandon adds, "And I'm a really good listener." See, the biggest challenge I see [00:05:40] with consultative sales training is they will say differentiation is the person.
The ability to create relationship, ask questions, [00:05:50] and listen intently. And once again, those are amazing skills, and we all need them, but that's not differentiation. [00:06:00] Those are commodities. Those are baseline expectations of salespeople. Reason two, Brandon did free [00:06:10] consulting for his competitor. He found a gap.
Where do you think that gap went? Straight to the incumbent. "Hey, Charlie, can you match this?" [00:06:20] We call that the last look. Brandon did the diagnosis, and the incumbent did the renewal. Consultative selling turned [00:06:30] Brandon into his competitor's best unpaid consultant. Reason three, it has no plan for the incumbent.[00:06:40]
Every step of consultative selling goes rapport, needs, solution, close. Nowhere does it say somebody else has to get [00:06:50] fired first. The incumbent has a relationship and has had it for years. Consultative selling teaches Brandon how to build a relationship. It never [00:07:00] teaches him how to break one. Now, Brandon didn't need better questions.
He needed a different kind of question, and he needed the sale to be about the buyer [00:07:10] instead of about him, and that's what the wedge does, and all of it happens before you ever ask for the policies or run a quote. First is [00:07:20] picture perfect. This question is designed with purpose to get the buyer clear on what their current agent isn't doing for them.
You do it without ever [00:07:30] saying anything bad about the incumbent. You are not throwing the other guy under the bus. You are raising the expectations of your buyer and enabling [00:07:40] them to discover the incumbent agent isn't playing at that level. And then comes the vision box, where you engage the buyer to tell you how they want [00:07:50] those services delivered.
The what, the how, the when, and the why. This is where active listening matters most. Consultative selling got that skill [00:08:00] right, it just never told you where to point it. And then you replay it back to them to confirm that's really what they want. Then you wave the white [00:08:10] flag. You surrender. "Hey, there's your game plan.
What would you like for me to do?" Now the ball is in their court. It's their [00:08:20] decision, not your pitch. And when they ask you to act on their behalf, you've earned the right to take them through the rehearsal. You walk them through what's going to [00:08:30] happen next. "Hey, when your agent finds out you're about to make this change, they're gonna come in with a wine and cheese basket.
They'll say, 'Here, you pop the top on the wine,' they're gonna slice the [00:08:40] cheese, and they're gonna tell you everything they've done for you over the years, and they're gonna ask you, 'Please, do not make this change.' When they do, [00:08:50] how are you gonna handle it?" Hey, the incumbent doesn't really come in with a wine and cheese basket.
That's a parody. A parody is a [00:09:00] deliberate, exaggerated imitation of a situation, sometimes for comic effect. It takes a familiar concept and kind of blows its recognizable traits out [00:09:10] of proportion to make a point. In reality, if the incumbent generally wants to keep the account, they're gonna use guilt, [00:09:20] loyalty, shame, and fear all put on the table at once.
And here's what I think happened to Brandon between Friday and Monday. His prospect got [00:09:30] the basket of fear, loyalty, and guilt. Brandon never prepared him for it, so the prospect didn't know what to say to his current guy, so the easy way out was to tell [00:09:40] Brandon the difference in price wasn't great enough to justify a change.
So key principle number one: if they can't fire the incumbent, [00:09:50] they can't hire you. The wedge assumes your price will be competitive, not necessarily better. What separates you from the incumbent is [00:10:00] the service. And before you ever decide to invest your time marketing the account and preparing a quote, you know what the buyer wants, you know their agent isn't [00:10:10] giving it to them, and you've rehearsed them through how they're going to end it.
So here's one thing to do on your next middle market account. Don't [00:10:20] go in there with the intent to ask for the policies and get a chance to quote. Before you show up, find out who the incumbent is, and then do your analysis. If they have that [00:10:30] guy, why do they need me? And then start defining the proactive services you do that the incumbent is probably not doing, and that's where you'll find your [00:10:40] prospect's pain.
And if you can't find any pain, does it really make sense to quote? See, if you do, you're just keeping their current guy honest. [00:10:50] Look, over the next seven episodes I'm taking the seven core behaviors that's one of the biggest sales consultative training firms on [00:11:00] the planet teaches, one at a time. I'll give each one credit where it's due, and I'll show you exactly where it breaks when there's an incumbent and everybody has [00:11:10] access to the same carriers.
Rule one of seven is next, and if you think I'm wrong about the consultative selling, tell me in the comments. I wanna [00:11:20] hear.